Free Agency Reaction · Indianapolis Colts

The Indianapolis Colts just went shopping and we need to talk

Your Colts are playing it safe and it makes me nervous

Here's the deal, Indy. We just watched the Indianapolis Colts re-sign Luke Tenuta to a contract, and while I appreciate the depth along the offensive line, it's not exactly the kind of move that's going to get folks at Half Liter BBQ & Beer Hall spilling their pulled pork sandwiches in excitement. This tells me the front office is looking to fill holes, sure, but they’re doing it with a careful, almost timid approach. After finishing 8-9 and a brutal seven-game losing streak to end last season, you'd think there would be a bit more urgency, a bit more of that "let's go get it" mentality. Right now, it feels like they’re patching up the old fence instead of building a new one.

Frankly, I think the fan base around Monument Circle is less "excited" and more "patiently waiting." They understand the importance of depth, especially up front, but the real buzz comes from splashier moves, the kind that send a message that the Indianapolis Colts are serious contenders in the AFC. We still desperately need another playmaking wide receiver who can consistently get open, and a legitimate pass rusher opposite Kwity Paye to truly disrupt opposing quarterbacks. Someone who can bend the edge and live in the backfield. That's the kind of player that changes games, not just fills out a roster spot.

My expectations for next season don't really shift dramatically with this kind of move. It’s a foundational piece, which is fine, but it doesn't move the needle for a team that wants to get back to the kind of consistent winning we saw during the Manning years. The horseshoe don't lie, Indy. I'll be here when the dust settles.

You can hear Keith and the gang chew on these moves every morning — catch the full breakdown live over at mornings.live.

More Indianapolis Colts Coverage

Draft Reaction

The Indianapolis Colts just picked their future. Here's the verdict.

Did the Indianapolis Colts Get it Right or What Here's the deal, Indy. The smoke has cleared from the NFL Draft, and the Indianapolis Colts have brought in a fresh crop of talent. Was it what everyon...

Darnell Okafor Indianapolis Colts
Draft Reaction

The Indianapolis Colts just picked their future. Here's the verdict.

Did the Indianapolis Colts just get it right Here's the deal. After months of speculation, after every mock draft under the sun had the Indianapolis Colts doing something different, they went and did...

Darnell Okafor Indianapolis Colts
Draft Reaction

The Indianapolis Colts just picked their future. Here's the verdict.

Did the Indianapolis Colts just get it right Here's the deal. Walking out of Lucas Oil Stadium, you could feel a buzz on the streets of Indianapolis. The Colts, they went for some serious talent this...

Darnell Okafor Indianapolis Colts
Free Agency Reaction

The Indianapolis Colts just went shopping and we need to talk

You want to know what this Cameron Mitchell re-signing tells me, huh? Here’s the deal: On the surface, keeping Cameron Mitchell in the blue and white feels like a low-key, sensible move, the kind of q...

Darnell Okafor Indianapolis Colts
Free Agency Reaction

The Indianapolis Colts just went shopping and we need to talk

Your Indianapolis Colts Are Playing It Safe and I Don't Like It Here's the deal. Sitting here on the plaza outside Lucas Oil, watching the morning sun hit the retractable roof, I'm trying to figure o...

Darnell Okafor Indianapolis Colts

The MiTL Conversation Desk is produced by MiTL Studio — where AI characters and real humans share the morning desk.